patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!
Local Voices

Local Matters: Some Villages Have All the Cash



I sometimes find myself marveling over the masonry and metal structures that Countryside has erected along LaGrange Road (see photo).  What is the purpose of these structures?  What did they cost?  And how could Countryside afford to construct all these doodads?

To investigate the last question I thought we could compare Countryside with its next door neighbor, the perennially penniless Indian Head Park.   


   
 

    Countryside    
 

  Indian Head Park    
 

  Population
 

  5,895
 

  3,809
 

  Median Household Income
 

  $61,941
 

  $70,485
 

  Budget (without TIF)
 

  $16,391,000
 

  $3,701,000
 

  Budget per capita (w/o TIF)   
 

  $2,780
 

  $971
 

Countryside is about half-again as large as Indian Head Park while IHP shows a slight 10% advantage over Countryside in median household income. 

But I want to focus on the last two lines of the table.  Note that the Countryside budget is over four times the size of IHP’s.  Even on a per capita basis, Countryside’s budget is still almost three times IHP’s.

Of course, Countryside’s budget is much larger because the town is blessed with a huge number of retail establishments, particularly car dealerships and food franchises.  This enables the municipal government to rake in all sorts of sales and other taxes. 

To continue our comparison:  


   
 
  Countryside     Indian Head Park  
$ % $

  Budget (without TIF)   
 

  $16,391,000
 

  100%
 

  $3,701,000
 

  100%
 

  Property Taxes
 

  $1,475,000
 

  9.0%
 

  $852,000
 

  23.0%
 

  State Sales Tax
 

  $4,850,000
 

  29.6%
 

  $290,000
 

  7.8%
 

  State Income Tax
 

  $462,000
 

  2.8%
 

  $343,500
 

  9.2%
 

Countryside’s property taxes are about half-again-as-much as IHP’s, about in line with their half-again-as-much population.  But note the huge State Sales Tax that Countryside brings in – it’s larger than the entire IHP budget!  I guess the three secrets to village finances are “location, location, location”.

There’s really not much Indian Head Park can do about this disparity.  IHP can continue to attempt to build out the Triangle (the area south of Joliet Road and west of Wolf Road).  But that land has been vacant for a while and, with our anemic economic recovery, no one is rushing to buy in.

So, yes, Countryside is awash in cash, so awash in cash that they can easily afford to build civic decorations such as those mini-towers.   There are 10 of these strung along LaGrange Road:

  • Four at the corner of 57th and LaGrange Road (at the Arby’s/McDonald’s
    intersection).
  • Four where 58th dead-ends onto LaGrange Road (near Church’s Fried
    Chicken).
  • Two at the drainage channel across from Countryside plaza (see second photo).

What are these things?  They don’t offer shelter from the storm and they aren’t designed to give foot-weary folks a place to sit.  They don’t provide light or give directions or information.  They hardly add to the ambiance of LaGrange Road.

Best as I can determine, they are an exercise in pushing the Countryside brand.  The mini-towers are evocative of the clock-tower at 55th and Plainfield, and their top white panel displays the new Countryside logo, which itself contains a drawing of the clock-tower.

But are they worth hundreds of thousands of dollars?  Surely, the money could have been better spent on, say, residential sidewalks.  Or, as I write this there are half-a-million people without power on the East Coast – perhaps Countryside should spend the money on burying their overhead electrical cables.  This would not only protect the cables from ice and wind storms, but would be something of a beautification campaign.  Or perhaps they could build bus stop shelters.  Or lower tax rates.  Or maybe give some cash to Indian Head Park.  ; )

Of course, Countryside is not the only village around here that’s splurging on civic doodads.  A few years ago Western Springs spent hundreds of thousands of dollars dismantling what seemed to me to be a perfectly functional train station.  Now that old station was certainly not as cute or picturesque as today’s station but did Western Springs need to spend all that money on “quaint”?  And what’s with the non-functioning tower there (see 3rd photo) – who thought that was a good idea?

I used to think that local village governments were more responsible and had less pork in their budgets than the state or federal pork-fests we’re treated to.  Now, I’m not so sure.

                                       - - - - - -

Craig's note: the budget numbers above come from the 2011-2012 budgets on respective Countryside and Indian Head Park websites.  I apologize for any inadvertent miscategorization.

 

 

Comment_arrow

Craig Fisher

8:44 am on Thursday, February 14, 2013

Chester, thanks. That's an interesting article. I thought maybe a later column would list all the red light cameras in the area, as a public service. : ) Thanks for reading.

Patch_comments_icon

Darren McRoy

5:33 pm on Wednesday, February 13, 2013

Craig, just wanted to say, I truly love your posts. I wish I had the time to cover more things from our smaller neighbor towns like IHP and Countryside, and I really appreciate your insights.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Craig Fisher

8:45 am on Thursday, February 14, 2013

Thanks for the encouragement, Darren. I'm having great fun, but it takes a lot longer to put together a weekly column than I expected. Whew.

Tom Hinshaw

4:58 pm on Thursday, February 14, 2013

Craig, another good story. You have a great way to report on and to highlight what is happening. Love your work. Please keep up the good work!

Reply

Vicki Aleck Gumbiner

9:30 am on Friday, February 15, 2013

I lived in Countryside from 1984-2000. In the early 90's I asked for sidewalks in 'The Triangle' an interior area where I lived. Mayor LeGant said they would put sidewalks in if I could get 75% approval. I could not. Most of the residence in 'The Triangle' area did not want sidewalks. At that time, Countryside City Council was responsive to residence suggestions.
How many years did it take to get the sidewalk on Plainfield Road? A road students use to walk to school.
You don't like the towers. You don't live in Countryside.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Craig Fisher

9:59 am on Friday, February 15, 2013

Vicki, the sidewalks on Plainfield Road in Indian Head Park were paid for by the "impact fees" that Dartmoor gave to IHP as a result of the Timber Trails development. I seem to remember that it cost around $75,000. I was not a big fan of the sidewalk, at least until after it was installed, and now I love it. : )

No, I don't like the little towers along LaGrange Road. I was driving there the other day during a rain storm and saw a bedraggled citizen waiting for the bus not 10 yards north of one of these mini-tower installations. I am sure that that citizen would have preferred a practical bus shelter to the decorative mini-towers.

Do you like the mini-towers? Would you have spent the money on them?

Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Darren McRoy

2:32 pm on Friday, February 15, 2013

People think bus shelters are ugly, and I can sympathize somewhat. But in the pouring rain or pounding blizzard, they suddenly become a lot more beautiful.

Vicki Aleck Gumbiner

2:13 pm on Friday, February 15, 2013

I contacting a Countryside alderman and it should be noted that 'No local tax money was spent on the structures. The funds came from a state grant that included the new street lights on LaGrange Road.'

Reply
Comment_arrow

Craig Fisher

3:09 pm on Friday, February 15, 2013

"No local tax money?" This means that every Illinoisian reading this helped pay for those decorations. Jeez, Vicki, what's even worse than wasting your own tax revenue is wasting someone else's. No wonder that Illinois has the second worst credit rating among the states (Illinois A+, California A- ; 31 states have AAA ratings).

Vicki Aleck Gumbiner

4:17 pm on Friday, February 15, 2013

I see your point, but I would add that they are better versed on what is available to communities. The question I would ask is what are IHP or any other communities local government doing to acquire funds to improve their communities. People will often disagree on how funds are used, but do your officials even know they exist and how to apply for them?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Craig Fisher

4:50 pm on Friday, February 15, 2013

>>do your officials even know they exist and how to apply for them?<<
I wondered that as I was doing the research.

Countryside's latest budget document says this: "A total of six grants have been budgeted as revenue totaling $657,231." These grants alone total about 1/6th of the entire IHP budget. IHP's grants line item is about $100K, so Countryside is kicking IHP's rear end in grabbing that grant money.

Leave a comment