The Christmas Tree Debate: Keep it Real, or Go Fake?
Readers can share their Christmas tree memories, share photos and discuss which style of tree they prefer in their home this season.
A funny thing begins to happen around town the first weekend after Thanksgiving.
Suddenly, tightly wrapped trees are being strapped to the roofs of family cars with bungy cords and driven home. Soon, these will be set up in the living room, wrapped in lights (once untangled of course), and decked with colored balls, pre-school-era ornaments, tinsel, or just about anything else these days.
Tell us what you decorate your tree with in comments below.
But not every family goes through the motions of picking up their tree at a nearby lot, or heading out to the farm to cut one down. Instead, they simply head up to the attic to dust off the same one they used last year.
To go real, or fake: that's the question.
Personally, I love a real tree. The evergreen smell, the family trip and debate over which one looks best is something that just brings out the season in me. You'd have a hard time convincing me to go fake—except, maybe, for one of those shiny aluminum ones from the 60s. Those are wild!
Christmas Tree Trivia
The Germans are most often credited with starting the modern Christmas tree tradition in the 1600s. According to the History Channel, they didn't take off in America though, until the late 1800s, with the first trees sold commercially in 1850.
Aluminum Christmas trees were the first artifical ones sold in a color other than green. They were originally crafted by a Chicago-based company called Modern Coatings. Alumnium trees were most popular in the 60s, and some credit the Charlie Brown Christmas Special that first aired in 1965 with killing the aluminum tree.
About six species of trees account for about 90 percent of Christmas tree market: Scotch pine, Douglas fir, noble fir, white pine, balsam fir and white spruce.
Share a picture of your Christmas tree from past or present by clicking the Upload Photos and Videos button. Tell us about your family's tree tradition in comments below and vote in our poll about which type you prefer to trim.
robert poznanski
12:10 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012
Every year, I say "lets go get an artificial tree", and every year, we go get a real one! Tradition, is a hard thing, to break! Guess that's why watering it, decorating ,and cleaning up (the needles) every year,are some things that will continue, till we can't physically do it any more!It just won't be the same, when that time comes!
David Potter
1:18 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012
I never once in my life considered cutting, buying, putting up ,decorating, and finally taking down a Christmas tree work. It's actually some of my fondest memories.
Vegasdog.
2:04 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012
Trees are like love. In the beginning, you go to a tree farm or a parking lot strung with lights and find one, take it home to your first little apartment or house, find out it's hopelessly crooked and needs to be propped up, put your "our first christmas" ornament on...it's all about the romance. In our old(er) age, it's a little more about the convenience of a "fake" tree: getting it up, putting on the lights then back in the box. So much for romance. Ultimately there's really nothing like the charm of a real tree however it's a young man's game. For those of us discovering and living with our old age, artificial may lack the romance but can still warm a room none the less.
David Potter
5:02 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012
Well said and I can understand. But to me having a fake Christmas tree would be like having a chicken for Thanksgiving dinner!
Matthew Hendrickson
6:56 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012
Thanks for your comments, readers!